September 1, 2011

Preseason perspectives

By Christan Shirk did a preseason Top 25 for the first time this year and it's hard to argue with choosing the defending and 8-time champion Messiah as preseason favorite.  Yes, they lost two All-American midfielders who combined for 16 assists and 31 goals, 15 which were game-winners, but replacing top players and returning to the Final Four is what Messiah has been doing for a decade now.  It will be interesting to see how quickly Messiah adjusts to life after Pezon and Nick Thompson, and that might depend on how effective target forward Josh Wood can be coming back from a whole season lost to injury and if freshman Jack Thompson, a playmaking midfielder, can hit the deck running at the collegiate level.  Those things could be key to whether they come out the gates looking like a No. 1 team or not.

But enough already about Messiah.  How does everyone else stack up going into the new season?  Who was ranked and why?  Who missed out and why? And did the voters get it right?  Now, to be sure, meaningful preseason rankings in Division III soccer is a highly difficult proposition.  It’s nearly impossible to make nationwide comparisons among 50 or so schools (the minimum that should be under consideration) never mind the 400-plus D-III schools.  First, many schools do note make available information regarding incoming players and non-graduation departures.  Second, the information available isn’t being compiled.  And third, there are just too many schools to realistically expect anyone to do a thorough study without being paid to do so, which is largely why item two isn’t happening.

But to the extent that information is available and time is taken to make comparisons, what should be considered?  Jim Matson, in his Daily Dose blog post A preseason Top 25, already listed most things to be studied: returning players, new players, variables from last season’s success or failures, and schedules.  With returning players we want to consider more than just the quantity of players and starters but also their production and contributions.  And conversely one needs to look at what a team lost—how critical were those players to the team’s success and can they be adequately replaced.  I would also add class distribution: is a team senior-laden possibly indicating experience, leadership, and composure?  Finally, given the difficulty of the task, I would suggest letting the conferences’ pre-season coaches’ polls inform the ranking.  Coaches will know much more about lost and returning players and the relative strength and potential of their conference rivals than someone from another conference or region.  You can’t ignore a solid conference’s favorite, and likewise caution should be taken before ranking a school that is only expected to be third or fourth best in their conference.

Working along those lines, there’s a few schools that I want to highlight because I think they have a very good shot to exceed the voters’ expectations.

Christopher Newport Captains If you wanted to make the case for another school as the pre-season #1, you can make a credible case for Christopher Newport.  In 2010 the Captains were receiving first place votes all season long, holding the #1 ranking for a few weeks in the middle part of the regular season.  Entering the tournament as the #2 ranked team, they bowed out to Johns Hopkins on a double-overtime goal in the second round and at 20-2-1 (4th best in D-III) were tabbed #11 when the dust had settled on the season.  The squad returns eight starters from last years' campaign, including five 1st team and two 2nd team all-conference selections, three NSCAA All-Region selections, and two All-Americans: forward Winston Mattheisen (10g, 8 a) and midfielder Brian Lybert (10g, 15a).  So, unlike Messiah, their top two attackers are back.  Overall, over 80% of their offensive production in 2010 returns (54 of 65 goals, 52 of 58 assists).  And not only are the top players back, but they are predominately seniors including a third-year starter in goal.  This team is tournament tested (Elite 8 in 2008 and 2009), beat Trinity in Texas last season and might be the strongest Captains team ever.

St. Lawrence University Saints A team that people should definitely keep an eye on as a potential title contender this year is St. Lawrence.  A little over a decade ago they were national champions and remained in the hunt for a second title through the mid-2000's.  But their star had fallen some from 2005 to 2009 to the point that few would have still named them as one of D-III's elite programs after they missed the NCAA tournament with a 8-6-1 record in 2009.  That damaged reputation was reflected by Top 25 voters largely ignoring them in 2010 until the final regular season rankings despite amassing a 16-2-2 record and 16-game unbeaten streak heading into the NCAA tournament.  Losing to Amherst 3-2 in the second round despite twice as many shots and shots on goal meant a 17-3-2 record was not good enough for a Top 25 ranking.  That snub possibly kept them from getting a closer look from some of the voters this pre-season which might suit Coach Durocher just fine to keep the team grounded.  But this team could be something special.  Ten starters are back from last year representing over 80% of their goals (36 of 44) and assists (37 of 42) in 2010.  Returning are their top five scorers including two NSCAA All-Americans: forward Brandon Gorman (7g, 4a) and midfielder Sam DeMello (8g, 9a).  The starting line-up figures to consist of five seniors, five juniors, and a sophomore who started every game his first season.  If they build on the success of last year, they could be among the best in 2011.

Wheaton College Thunder I think the voters' cautious take on Wheaton (Ill.) is sensible, but I'd guess few will be surprised if they do much better than #24.  Last year was one of growing pains for a squad featuring 24 freshmen and sophomores and Wheaton's typical killer non-conference schedule (three teams finished ranked in the top 6, two more Top 25, and two more receiving votes) was too much for the youngsters who dropped six and tied three in posting a very uncharacteristic 2-6-3 mark before entering conference play.  That experience and the generally easier competition resulted in the Thunder winning their next nine in a row before losing 3-2 in overtime in the conference final to a North Park side the had beaten 3-1 a month earlier.  It meant the team missed out on the NCAA's for the first time in 17 seasons.  As painful as that was for the Wheaton faithful, the experience gained from the tough schedule and the sting of falling short of the program's traditional success should propel this years' squad to unqualified success.  Those freshmen and sophomores are now sophomores and juniors, and it should be remembered that Wheaton was competitive in every loss or tie last year, only once losing by more than 1 goal and going to overtime five times.  The non-conference schedule is a little more reasonable this time around, though still among the toughest, but it's reasonable to expect some of last year's ties to become wins and some of the losses to become ties or wins this season.  How many will determine if this time is good or great.

New York University Violets After New York University's surprising emergence and run to the Final Four in 2006 the team suffered through two losing seasons in 2008 and 2009.  That made them a surprise success again in 2010 when they captured the UAA title (their first) before a heart-breaking 3-2 first round tournament loss to Brockport State after leading 2-0 a half hour in.  They finished about five spots outside the Top 25 and found themselves similarly rated in the current pre-season poll.  They sit beneath fellow UAA rivals Emory (#10), Washington (#17), and even Carnegie Mellon (RV) who just edged them.  But the UAA coaches, who it should be safe to assume have a better knowledge of how their teams stack up against each other than other observers from all across the country, selected NYU as its clear preseason favorite with five of eight first place votes. Emory followed in second without a single first place vote, then Rochester and Washington in third and fourth with one and two first place votes respectively.  It's not a case of thinking the voters got it wrong with Emory and Washington, but rather that NYU might deserve to be up there with them. All three of those schools bring back seven starters and all three have the bulk of their offensive output returning.  All three lost two All-UAA defenders or goalkeepers. With similar losses and retention, the defending champions who didn't allow any goals in conference play a year ago probably merit a little more respect from outside their conference.

In closing, a few schools that are probably off the radar that I think might prove to be Top 25 teams are Ohio Northern, Hamilton, Nazareth, Redlands, and Claremont-Mudd-Scripps.

Comments or feedback for the author?  Email Christan Shirk.

Want to discuss this article with other fans?  Opine here.

Jim Matson, Christan Shirk, Ryan Harmanis, and other staff writers and contributors help cover the games and results across the nation.

Questions or comments?

»  E-mail
Feb 28: Middlebury's Saward to retire after 2017 season
Nov 7: Midweek Wrap - Week 10
Nov 6: Upstate Update - Conference Playoff Edition
Nov 4: Women's Watch - Weekend #10
Nov 3: Week 10 Midwest Roundup
Oct 31: Midweek Wrap - Week 9
Oct 29: Week 9 Midwest Roundup
Oct 28: Upstate Update - Week 9
Oct 28: Women's Watch - Weekend #9
Oct 24: Midweek Wrap - Week 8
Oct 22: Week 8 Midwest Roundup
Oct 22: Upstate Update - Week 8
Oct 20: Women's Watch - Weekend #8
Oct 17: Midweek Wrap - Week 7
Oct 15: Week 7 Midwest Roundup
Oct 14: Upstate Update - Week 7
Oct 13: Women's Watch - Weekend #7
Oct 10: Midweek Wrap - Week 6
Oct 8: Week 6 Midwest Roundup
Oct 7: Upstate Update - Week 6
Oct 6: Women's Watch - Weekend #6
Oct 3: Midweek Wrap - Week 5
Oct 1: Midwest Roundup - Week 5
Sep 30: Upstate Update - Week 5
Sep 29: Women's Watch - Weekend #5
Sep 26: Midweek Wrap - Week 4
Sep 23: Midwest Roundup - Week 4
Sep 22: Upstate Update - Week 4
Sep 22: Women's Watch - Weekend #4
Sep 19: Midweek Wrap - Week 3
Sep 17: Midwest Roundup - Week 3
Sep 15: Upstate Update - Week 3
Sep 12: Midweek Wrap - Week 2
Sep 9: Midwest Roundup - Week 2
Sep 9: Upstate Update - Week 2
Sep 8: Women's Watch - Weekend #2
Sep 8: D-III soccer represented among Top 30 honorees for NCAA Woman of the Year
Sep 4: Midweek Wrap - Week 1
Sep 3: Midwest Roundup - Week 1
Aug 29: Curtains on three coaching legends
Aug 25: Midwest Roundup - 2014 Men's Preview
Nov 22: Getting to know the 2013 men's Sweet 16
Nov 10: Men's at-large berth analysis and predictions
Nov 7: AQ's, Pool B and Pool C? What does it all mean?
Oct 23: New criteria debuts in today's NCAA Regional Rankings
Sep 15: Week 3 Flybys, weekend edition
Aug 29: What's new in 2013?
Nov 14: Welcome to the Sweet 16, Part 2: the Men
Nov 13: Welcome to the Sweet 16, Part 1: the Women
Nov 4: At-large berth analysis and predictions
Nov 3: AQ's, Pool B and Pool C? What does it all mean?
Oct 1: Dear Men's Top 25 Voters
Sep 22: Week 4 Flybys, weekend edition
Sep 21: Week 4 Flybys, midweek edition
Sep 17: Week 3 Flybys
Sep 4: Labor Day Weekend Flybys
Sep 3: New rules, new conference, name changes
Aug 31: 2012 Preseason Flybys (INCOMPLETE)
Nov 14: Hellooooo Neumann!
Nov 13: A Super Saturday to like and dislike
Nov 6: At-large berth analysis and predictions
Nov 4: So what's this talk about AQ's, Pool B and Pool C?
Oct 24: Week 8 Flyby Distractions
Oct 19: NCAA Regional Rankings (aka 'The Rankings that Matter')
Oct 17: Week 7 Flybys, Conference Edition
Oct 14: Midseason stars and surprises
Oct 8: Week 6 Flybys, weekend edition
Oct 6: Week 6 Flybys, midweek edition
Oct 1: Week 5 Flybys, weekend edition
Sep 29: Week 5 Flybys, midweek edition
Sep 26: Did you know?
Sep 19: Who's top dog after 3 weeks?
Sep 10: Friday Notes, Weekend Questions
Sep 2: Off with a bang!
Sep 1: Preseason perspectives
Sep 1: After 17 years, trailblazer calls it a day
Dec 4: Inside the women's semifinals
Dec 4: Messiah takes the title in overtime
Dec 3: The stalwart against the upstart
Nov 30: Men's NCAA semifinal preview
Nov 30: Women's NCAA semifinal preview
Nov 21: NCAA men: Welcome to San Antonio!
Nov 21: NCAA women: Sunday's wins are a ticket to Texas
Nov 20: Sweet Saturday: HSU, Oshkosh are on to Texas
Nov 18: NCAA Sweet 16 men's preview
Nov 17: NCAA Sweet 16 women's preview
Nov 7: The AQs are in! Weekend in review
Oct 24: Big weekend for ranked teams
Oct 24: Hardin-Simmons keeps rolling
Oct 17: Did CNU's goal beat the clock?