| School | Location | Conf. | Head Coach |
|---|
| Alfred Saxons | Alfred, NY | E8 | Scott Miller (Alfred '96) |
| Bard Raptors | Annandale-on-Hudson, NY | SKY | Scott Swere (Cortland State) |
| Baruch Bearcats | New York, NY | CUNYAC | Ranford Champagnie (St. John's, N.Y. '99) |
| Brockport State Golden Eagles | Brockport, NY | SUNYAC | Gary LaPietra (St. John Fisher) |
| Brooklyn Bridges | Brooklyn, NY | CUNYAC | Rawle Hensford (York, N.Y.) |
| Buffalo State Bengals | Buffalo, NY | SUNYAC | Rudy Pompert |
| Cazenovia Wildcats | Cazenovia, NY | NEAC | Eric Bonnier (Brockport State '91) |
| CCNY Beavers | New York, NY | CUNYAC | Robert Ignaccolo |
| Clarkson Golden Knights | Potsdam, NY | LL | Willi Steinrotter (Hobart '89) |
| Cortland State Red Dragons | Cortland, NY | SUNYAC | Dwight Hornibrook (New Brunswick '82) |
| D'Youville Spartans | Buffalo, NY | AMCC | Matthew McCormick (Rochester Tech) |
| Elmira Soaring Eagles | Elmira, NY | E8 | Jeremiah Kneeland (Elmira '95) |
| Farmingdale State Rams | Farmingdale, NY | SKY | Chuck Schimpf (Southern Connecticut) |
| Fredonia State Blue Devils | Fredonia, NY | SUNYAC | PJ Gondek (Cortland State) |
| Geneseo State Blue Knights | Geneseo, NY | SUNYAC | Mike Mooney (Canisius '85) |
| Hamilton Continentals | Clinton, NY | LL | Perry Nizzi (Cortland State '97) |
| Hilbert Hawks | Hamburg, NY | AMCC | Not available |
| Hobart Statesmen | Geneva, NY | LL | Shawn Griffin (Plymouth State '88) |
| Hunter Hawks | New York, NY | CUNYAC | Jose Cedeno |
| Ithaca Bombers | Ithaca, NY | E8 | Andy Byrne (Plymouth State '75) |
| John Jay Bloodhounds | New York, NY | CUNYAC | |
| Keuka Storm | Keuka Park, NY | NEAC | Matthew Tantalo (Rochester Tech '99) |
| Medaille Mavericks | Buffalo, NY | AMCC | Not available |
| Medgar Evers Cougars | Brooklyn, NY | CUNYAC | |
| Morrisville State Mustangs | Morrisville, NY | NEAC | Tom Davian (Buffalo State '71) |
| Mount St. Mary Knights | Newburgh, NY | SKY | Doug Stahl (Manchester '96) |
| Mount St. Vincent Dolphins | Riverdale, NY | SKY | Brian Dunleavy (Hofstra '04) |
| Nazareth Golden Flyers | Rochester, NY | E8 | Danny Gilbertson (Plymouth State) |
| New Paltz State Hawks | New Paltz, NY | SUNYAC | Eric Watson (Williams '97) |
| New York City Tech Yellow Jackets | Brooklyn, NY | CUNYAC | Jose Luis Rebay |
| New York University Violets | New York, NY | UAA | Joe Behan (NYU '95) |
| Oneonta State Red Dragons | Oneonta, NY | SUNYAC | Iain Byrne (Empire State) |
| Oswego State Lakers | Oswego, NY | SUNYAC | Robert Friske (Plattsburgh State '91) |
| Plattsburgh State Cardinals | Plattsburgh, NY | SUNYAC | Chris Waterbury (Cortland State '81) |
| Polytechnic Bluejays | Brooklyn, NY | SKY | Nate Kalin (Lycoming) |
| Potsdam State Bears | Potsdam, NY | SUNYAC | |
| Rochester Yellowjackets | Rochester, NY | UAA | Chris Appple (Rochester '92) |
| Rochester Tech Tigers | Rochester, NY | E8 | Bill Garno (Rochester Tech) |
| RPI Red Hawks | Troy, NY | LL | Adam Clinton (Keene State) |
| Skidmore Thoroughbreds | Saratoga Springs, NY | LL | Ron McEachen (West Virginia '69) |
| St. John Fisher Cardinals | Pittsford, NY | E8 | Rob Searle (Ohio Wesleyan) |
| St. Joseph's (L.I.) Golden Eagles | Patchogue, NY | SKY | Gary Smith |
| St. Lawrence Saints | Canton, NY | LL | Bob Durocher (Ithaca) |
| Staten Island Dolphins | Staten Island, NY | CUNYAC | |
| Stevens Ducks | Hoboken, NJ | E8 | Tim O'Donohue (Muhlenberg '98) |
| SUNY-Cobleskill Fighting Tigers | Cobleskill, NY | NEAC | Not available |
| SUNY-Maritime Privateers | Throggs Neck, NY | SKY | Rocco Morelli (Maryland) |
| SUNY-Old Westbury Panthers | Old Westbury, NY | SKY | Jason Warchaw (Albany) |
| SUNY-Purchase Panthers | Purchase, NY | SKY | Paul Brooks |
| SUNYIT Wildcats | Utica, NY | NEAC | Peterson Jerome |
| Union Dutchmen | Schenectady, NY | LL | Jeff Guinn (North Carolina State '86) |
| Utica Pioneers | Utica, NY | E8 | Steven Christensen (Roberts Wesleyan) |
| Vassar Brewers | Poughkeepsie, NY | LL | Andy Jennings (Exeter University) |
| Wells Express | Aurora, NY | NEAC | Michael Paolini (Plattsburgh State '99) |
| Yeshiva Maccabees | New York, NY | SKY | Tony Elmore |
| York (N.Y.) Cardinals | Jamaica, NY | CUNYAC | Linval Cunningham |
