| School | Location | Conf. | Head Coach |
|---|
| Augsburg Auggies | Minneapolis, MN | MIAC | Greg Holker (Gustavus Adolphus '00) |
| Beloit Buccaneers | Beloit, WI | MWC | Tim Schmiechen (Ohio Wesleyan '85) |
| Bethany Lutheran Vikings | Mankato, MN | UMAC | Rob Pipal |
| Bethel Royals | St. Paul, MN | MIAC | Pepe Jon Chavez |
| Buena Vista Beavers | Storm Lake, IA | IIAC | Scott Phipps (Park University) |
| Carleton Knights | Northfield, MN | MIAC | Bob Carlson (St. Olaf '86) |
| Carroll Pioneers | Waukesha, WI | MWC | Rick Mobley (Campbell '93) |
| Central Dutch | Pella, IA | IIAC | Garry Laidlaw (Eastern Illinois) |
| Coe Kohawks | Cedar Rapids, IA | IIAC | Homer Screws |
| Concordia-Moorhead Cobbers | Moorhead, MN | MIAC | Dan Weiler (MSU Moorhead '96) |
| Cornell Rams | Mount Vernon, IA | IIAC | Bryan Scales (Hartwick '91) |
| Crown Storm | St. Bonifacius, MN | UMAC | Josh Dunwoody (Faith Baptist Bible) |
| Dubuque Spartans | Dubuque, IA | IIAC | Bryan Scales (Loras) |
| Finlandia Lions | Hancock, MI | IND | Matt Griffith |
| Grinnell Pioneers | Grinnell, IA | MWC | Brian Jaworski (DePauw '88) |
| Gustavus Adolphus Gusties | St. Peter, MN | MIAC | Larry Zelenz (DePauw '78) |
| Hamline Pipers | St. Paul, MN | MIAC | Andy Coutts (St. Lawrence '99) |
| Illinois College Blue Boys/Lady Blues | Jacksonville, IL | MWC | Shane Taylor (Bethany College) |
| Knox Prairie Fire | Galesburg, IL | MWC | Lucas Robinson (Knox '94) |
| Lake Forest Foresters | Lake Forest, IL | MWC | Derek Niepomnik (Northern Illinois '96) |
| Lawrence Vikings | Appleton, WI | MWC | Blake Johnson (Springfield '84) |
| Loras Duhawks | Dubuque, IA | IIAC | Dan Rothert (Loras '96) |
| Luther Norse | Decorah, IA | IIAC | Chris Garcia-Prats (Trinity University '02) |
| Macalester Scots | St. Paul, MN | MIAC | Ian Barker (University of Warwick) |
| Minnesota-Morris Cougars | Morris, MN | UMAC | Christian DeVries (Adams State '91) |
| Monmouth Scots | Monmouth, IL | MWC | George Perry (Indiana) |
| Nebraska Wesleyan Prairie Wolves | Lincoln, NE | IND | James Beckmann (Nebraska Wesleyan '99) |
| North Central (Minn.) Rams | Minneapolis, MN | IND | TBA |
| Northland Jacks | Ashland, WI | UMAC | Scott Mayforth (Northland College '87) |
| Northwestern (Minn.) Eagles | St. Paul, MN | UMAC | Greg Wheaton (Liberty) |
| Presentation Saints | Aberdeen, SD | UMAC | Steve Cogley (Northern State '95) |
| Ripon Red Hawks | Ripon, WI | MWC | Todd Parker (St. Mary's University) |
| Simpson Storm | Indianola, IA | IIAC | Mike Wilson (Simpson '00) |
| St. John's Johnnies | Collegeville, MN | MIAC | Pat Haws (St. Johns '72) |
| St. Mary's (Minn.) Cardinals | Winona, MN | MIAC | Chris Dembiec (Marquette) |
| St. Norbert Green Knights | De Pere, WI | MWC | Andrew Steger |
| St. Olaf Oles | Northfield, MN | MIAC | Kurt Anderson (Augustana '72) |
| St. Scholastica Saints | Duluth, MN | UMAC | Barry Chastey |
| St. Thomas Tommies | St. Paul, MN | MIAC | Aaron Macke (St. Thomas '96) |
| UW-Oshkosh Titans | Oshkosh, WI | WIAC | Toby Bares (UW Stevens Point '76) |
| UW-Platteville Pioneers | Platteville, WI | WIAC | Enzo Fuschino (SUNY Buffalo '94) |
| UW-Superior Yellow Jackets | Superior, WI | WIAC | Joe Mooney (UW-Superior '06) |
| UW-Whitewater Warhawks | Whitewater, WI | WIAC | Greg Henschel (UW- Oshkosh) |
| Wartburg Knights | Waverly, IA | IIAC | TJ Buckholz (Northwestern College '99) |
